ARPA-E funded interactive dashboard (Python, Plotly, Dash) and optimization framework for U.S. Class I railroads to evaluate battery-electric, hydrogen, and biofuel locomotive deployment.
The Northwestern University Freight Rail Infrastructure & Energy Network Decarbonization (NUFRIEND) tool is an industry-grade simulation, techno-economic analysis (TEA), and optimization dashboard developed for the U.S. Department of Energy Advanced Research Projects Agency-Energy (ARPA-E).
Developed at the Northwestern University Transportation Center (NUTC) in collaboration with Argonne National Laboratory, NUFRIEND evaluates decarbonization pathways for U.S. Class I railroad networks across battery-electric, hydrogen fuel cell, and drop-in biofuels/e-fuels.
Left: NUFRIEND corridor simulation and facility siting interface. Right: Five-step NUFRIEND framework for alternative fuel conversion and charging/refueling infrastructure planning across U.S. Class I rail networks.
Key Capabilities
Facility Location & Sizing: Multi-stage optimization frameworks to determine optimal charging and alternative fueling facility locations along freight corridors under power grid and operational constraints.
Life-Cycle & Techno-Economic Analysis: End-to-end evaluation of capital expenditures (CAPEX), operational expenditures (OPEX), payload-range trade-offs, emissions reduction, and levelized abatement cost per kilogram of $\text{CO}_2$ mitigated.
Interactive Decision Support: Web-based dashboard built with Python, Plotly, and Dash enabling rail operators and policymakers to perform sensitivity analysis on locomotive range, battery pack energy density, and renewable fuel adoption.
To support planning of alternative fuel technology (e.g., battery-electric locomotives) deployment for decarbonizing non-electrified freight rail, we develop a convex optimization formulation with a closed-form solution to determine the optimal number of energy storage tender cars in a train. The formulation shares a similar structure to an Economic Order Quantity (EOQ) model. For given market characteristics, cost forecasts, and technology parameters, our model captures the trade-offs between inventory carrying costs associated with trip times (including delays due to charging/refueling) and ordering costs associated with train dispatch and operation (energy, amortized equipment, and labor costs). To illustrate the framework, we find the optimal number of battery-electric energy tender cars in 22,501 freight markets (origin–destination pairs and commodities) for U.S. Class I railroads. The results display heterogeneity in optimal configurations with lighter, yet more time-sensitive shipments (e.g., intermodal) utilizing more battery tender cars. For heavier commodities (e.g., coal) with lower holding costs, single battery tender car configurations are generally optimal. The results also show that the optimal train configurations are sensitive to delays associated with recharging or swapping tender cars.
@article{ng_trading_2024,title={Trading off energy storage and payload – {An} analytical model for freight train configuration},volume={187},issn={1366-5545},doi={10.1016/j.tre.2024.103601},urldate={2024-05-25},journal={Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review},author={Ng, Max T. M. and Hernandez, Adrian and Durango-Cohen, Pablo L. and Mahmassani, Hani S.},month=jul,year={2024},keywords={Battery tender, Battery-electric, Decarbonization, Energy storage tender cars, Rail freight},pages={103601},}
Optimizing service networks to support freight rail decarbonization: Flow selection, facility location, and energy sourcing
We present a framework to support decarbonization of energy intensive transportation systems offering periodic service on expansive networks (e.g., freight rail, trucking, and intercity bus services). The framework consists of two optimization problems that respectivelyaddress (i) flow selection and facility location, and (ii) energy sourcing/procurement at the service facilities to enable the selected flows. The framework generalizes mixed integer linear programming formulations for flow refueling facility location and flow-based set cover models appearing in the literature to situations where it is of interest to account for repositioning of assets along cyclical trajectories to allow for periodic service, and to account for intermediate flow capture (i.e., trip chaining). The framework also consists of a minimum cost network flow model to determine optimal energy sourcing and distribution strategies, which dictate capacity requirements at the service facilities. The energy demands are obtained from the solution to the flow selection and facility location model. To illustrate the framework, we analyze the deployment of charging stations to support battery-electric locomotive service on a subset of the US freight rail network (i.e., an aggregate network of 3 Class I Railroads). The results show that the deployment of 30 charging stations can support battery-electric locomotives (with 1600-km ranges) to serve 86% of distance-weighted flows (ton-km) and reduce emissions by approximately 50%.
@article{hernandez_optimizing_2024,issn={03772217},doi={10.1016/j.ejor.2024.04.010},language={en},urldate={2024-04-18},journal={European Journal of Operational Research},author={Hernandez, Adrian and Ng, Max and Durango-Cohen, Pablo L. and Mahmassani, Hani S.},month=apr,year={2024},pages={S0377221724002868},}
Abatement cost curve analysis of freight rail decarbonization alternatives
This paper investigates decarbonization alternatives for the freight rail industry, considering economic, environmental, and operational aspects. The study compares battery-electric and hydrogen fuel cell locomotives, drop-in fuels including biofuels and e-fuels, and overhead catenary electrification through abatement cost analyses. Scenario analysis identifies the cost-effectiveness of each of the technologies at different stages of decarbonization in the US Class 1 freight railroad network. We show that though battery locomotives offer a lower-cost decarbonization option in the considered scenarios, green hydrogen fuel-powered locomotives become more attractive when battery charging delays are considered. We introduce the concept of the technology margin to cater for uncertainties in battery charging operations and hydrogen fuel production for cases where carbon taxes are imposed on railroad operations. The study provides valuable insights for policymakers and rail operators, contributing to sustainable freight rail operations.
@article{hernandez_abatement_2024,title={Abatement cost curve analysis of freight rail decarbonization alternatives},volume={134},issn={1361-9209},doi={10.1016/j.trd.2024.104341},urldate={2024-08-06},journal={Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment},author={Hernandez, Adrian and Ng, Max T. M. and Siddique, Choudhury and Durango-Cohen, Pablo L. and Mahmassani, Hani S. and Elgowainy, Amgad and Wang, Michael and Zhou, Yan},month=sep,year={2024},keywords={Abatement cost, Alternative fuels, Decarbonization, Economic analysis, Freight rail},pages={104341},}
2023
Evaluation of Rail Decarbonization Alternatives: Framework and Application
The Northwestern University Freight Rail Infrastructure & Energy Network Decarbonization (NUFRIEND) framework is a comprehensive industry-oriented tool for simulating the deployment of new energy technologies including biofuels, e-fuels, battery-electric, and hydrogen locomotives. By classifying fuel types into two categories based on deployment requirements, the associated optimal charging/fueling facility location and sizing problem are solved with a five-step framework. Life-cycle analysis (LCA) and techno-economic analysis (TEA) are used to estimate carbon reduction, capital investments, cost of carbon reduction, and operational impacts, enabling sensitivity analysis with operational and technological parameters. The framework is illustrated on lower-carbon drop-in fuels as well as battery-electric technology deployments for the US Eastern and Western Class I railroad networks. Drop-in fuel deployments are modeled as admixtures with diesel in existing locomotives, while battery-electric deployments are shown for varying technology penetration levels and locomotive ranges. When mixed in a 50% ratio with diesel, results show biodiesel’s capacity to reduce emissions at 36% with a cost of 0.13 per kilogram of CO2 reduced, while e-fuels offer a potential reduction of 50% of emissions at a cost of 0.22 per kilogram of CO2 reduced. Battery-electric results for 50% deployment over all ton-miles highlight the value of future innovations in battery energy densities as scenarios assuming 800-mi range locomotives show an estimated emissions reduction of 46% with a cost of 0.06 per kilogram of CO2 reduced, compared with 16% emissions reduction at a cost of 0.11 per kilogram of CO2 reduced for 400-mi range locomotives. The NUFRIEND framework provides a systematic method for comparing different alternative energy technologies and identifying potential challenges and benefits in their future deployments.
@article{hernandez_evaluation_2023,title={Evaluation of {Rail} {Decarbonization} {Alternatives}: {Framework} and {Application}},issn={0361-1981},shorttitle={Evaluation of {Rail} {Decarbonization} {Alternatives}},doi={10.1177/03611981231170182},language={en},urldate={2023-07-17},journal={Transportation Research Record},author={Hernandez, Adrian and Ng, Max T. M. and Siddique, Nazib and Durango-Cohen, Pablo L. and Elgowainy, Amgad and Mahmassani, Hani S. and Wang, Michael and Zhou, Yan (Joann)},month=may,year={2023},pages={03611981231170182},}
ARPA-E Final Technical Report: Northwestern University Freight Rail Infrastructure and Energy Network Decarbonization
The goal of this project was to develop a tool to aid railroads and other stakeholders assess and approach the decarbonization of freight rail operations by identifying new, viable low-carbon energy storage and conversion systems for future locomotive systems and how they should be deployed on the existing US freight rail network. In the first quarter, the project focused on collecting data, establishing a simulation workflow, and engaging industry through the creation of the Industry Advisory Board (IAB). In the second quarter, the project focused on selecting fuel pathways and powertrain technologies, setting performance targets, conducting a techno-economic analyses, and developing the simulation framework that would serve as the backbone of the future toolhead. The third quarter involved developing an industry-oriented interactive dashboard powered by a five-step sequential framework, as well as holding industry advisory board meetings as per the initial technology-to-market plan. In the remaining project quarters, the NUFRIEND dashboard were fine-tuned with the help of IAB member feedback and in-depth scenario analyses were conducted to support the techno-economic analysis of energy sources. Additionally, dashboard documentation, project insights, and open-source code on GitHub were prepared and released. Throughout the project, the team completed testing and analysis of all model components, integrated all initial test scenarios, and conducted stakeholder engagement. Lower-carbon drop-in fuels can be deployed as admixtures and are considered uniform across the network at a desired penetration rate, while hydrogen and battery-electric technology deployment poses a more complex problem as they require significant investments to be made in the siting of refueling/charging facilities and the replacement of locomotive fleets. Thus, strategies for locating and sizing refueling/charging facilities on a railroad’s network to meet their energy demands were developed to inform deployment decisions. To address this challenge, the Northwestern University Freight Rail Infrastructure & Energy Network Decarbonization (NUFRIEND) framework presents a five-step sequential framework to select O-D paths, locate facilities, reroute flows, size facilities, and evaluate the deployment for alternative energy sources that require locomotive powertrains to be converted and new refueling infrastructure to be deployed.1 The NUFRIEND Framework is an industry-oriented tool for simulating the deployment of new energy technologies across the US freight rail network. The framework provides a comprehensive network-level optimization and scenario simulation tool for decarbonizing the freight rail sector, addressing the uncertainties surrounding technological developments by supporting sensitivity analyses for different operational and technological parameters through a transparent and flexible input module. It offers practical alternatives to diesel locomotives and can be applied for any railroad considering the specific network structure and freight demand, outputting evaluation metrics for the associated emissions and costs relative to diesel operations. A number of relevant simulation scenarios were run and analyzed for key insights on the value of different alternative technologies for freight rail decarbonization. The project developments and findings have been presented at numerous conferences and events.
@book{hernandez_arpa-e_2023,title={{ARPA}-{E} {Final} {Technical} {Report}: {Northwestern} {University} {Freight} {Rail} {Infrastructure} and {Energy} {Network} {Decarbonization}},shorttitle={{ARPA}-{E} {Final} {Technical} {Report}},language={en},urldate={2023-09-16},publisher={figshare},author={Hernandez, Adrian and Ng, Max T. M. and Siddique, Choudhury and Durango-Cohen, Pablo L. and Elgowainy, Amgad and Mahmassani, Hani and Wang, Michael and Zhou, Yan (Joann)},month=may,year={2023},doi={10.6084/m9.figshare.22674328.v3},}